Texas Construction Law Updates
Partial performance can overcome the absence of a written contractAaron Capps - Wednesday, November 15, 2017
In Thomas v. Miller, the lack of a written contract became the focal point of the dispute. Leorris Thomas verbally agreed to sell two acres of land to the Millers in exchange for payment of the amount remaining on Thomas’s mortgage. The Millers paid Thomas’s mortgage from 2004 to 2010 and made improvements to the property during that time. However, continual threats from Thomas caused the Millers to abandon the property in 2009. Thomas subsequently sold it to a third party.
The Millers sued and won their lawsuit against Thomas for breach of contract. Thomas appealed claiming the oral contract was unenforceable under the statute of frauds, which considers certain agreements unenforceable for a variety of reasons, including when they are not in writing.
The appellate court found the partial performance by the Millers was sufficient to trigger an exception to a statutory requirement for the contract to be in writing. It also found that refusing to enforce the contract would amount to a virtual fraud. The Millers relied on the contract to their substantial detriment, had no adequate remedy, and Thomas would reap an unearned benefit. The appellate court therefore affirmed the trial court’s ruling and enforced the oral contract.
The attached information is general in nature, is presented for discussion purposes only, and may not reflect current legal developments, nor fully explore all potential areas of this topic. The information included should not be relied upon or construed as legal advice and is not a substitute for obtaining legal advice from an attorney. No legal representation is undertaken or implied with the distribution of this information.
- Insurance claims can be denied completely unless the owner or contractor can show how much damage resulted from causes covered under the policy
- Liquidated-damage provision enforced by Houston Court of Appeals
- Texas Supreme Court refuses to look beyond the contract language to determine a party’s obligations
- 2017 Legislative Updates
- Construction contracts can incorporate documents executed by the parties without describing them with specificity
- Partial performance can overcome the absence of a written contract
- Arbitration agreement found unenforceable because employer could modify it without advance notice to the employee
- Challenges to overall enforceability of a contract can be determined by an arbitrator
- Failure to investigate contractor’s performance may prevent an owner from later recovering damages for latent defects
- Pay attention to the signature block and guaranty provisions when signing a contract
- Arbitration (2)
- Condition Precedent (1)
- Construction Contracts (5)
- Construction Defects (1)
- Employment Contracts (1)
- Federal Courts (1)
- Government Contracts (1)
- Guaranty Agreement (1)
- Indemnity (1)
- Individual Liability (1)
- Insurance (1)
- Legislative Update (1)
- Limitations (1)
- Notice of Claim (1)
- Real-Estate Contracts (1)
- Settlement Agreements (2)
- Trust Fund Act (1)